27个回答

如何看待武汉大学杨某某疑似正在武汉大学要求下修改自己的硕士学位论文?

无题
4194个点赞 👍

更新:已经拟好邮件草稿了,虽然这事是不是真有待进一步观察,可能是杨放的烟雾弹,但如果这事实锤,我就发给全球各大高校

Subject: Academic Scandal at Wuhan University

Dear Professors & Staffs,

On Behalf of China's Vast Student Community, I Expose Wuhan University's Systemic Protection of Academic Misconduct to the Global Academia

As a key "985 Project" university in China, Wuhan University has systematically shielded academic misconduct. Not only did it allow a master's thesis riddled with severe academic violations to pass review, but after public outcry, it openly permitted the involved student to withdraw her published thesis for tampering—utterly trampling on academic ethics and exposing the complete failure of its academic governance mechanisms.

Event Summary:

On May 1, 2024, the master's thesis titled Fertility and Domestic Violence: An Economic Study between China and India(link:中印生育行为影响家庭暴力的经济学分析 - 中国知网) by Wuhan University (WHU) student Yang Jingyuan passed the university’s internal review and was published on CNKI, China’s National Thesis Database. After being awarded her degree, Yang commenced doctoral studies at Hong Kong Baptist University.

On July 27,2025 the thesis was exposed for alleged plagiarism, fabrication of facts, data manipulation, suspected AI-generated content, and fundamental errors in its core model (evidence link:evidence evidence 1evidence 2evidence 3). As WHU is a prestigious 985 institution in China, this scandal went viral across Chinese social media, accumulating over 10 million views.

On the evening of August 5,2025 Yang uploaded a file titled Yang Jingyuan - Master’s Thesis Investigation and Review.zip to her cloud storage. The file, discovered by netizens and later deleted (Backup of this file:backup), contained "revisions" to her thesis and stated: "I am willing to actively cooperate with the university, faculty, and professors in future revisions, rigorously address existing issues, and enhance the rigor and standardization of my research." This implies the university has not initiated accountability procedures but tacitly permitted retraction and revision of a published thesis—setting a precedent that "major academic misconduct not only goes unpunished but can be retroactively edited." Such actions equate to allowing students to alter graded exam papers, desecrating academic integrity, undermining the dignity of honest scholars, and reducing oversight mechanisms to a mockery.

Nature of the Incident:

Systemic Academic Failure: A master’s thesis undergoes rigorous annual checks (proposal defense, blind review, oral defense). WHU’s approval of a thesis riddled with flaws exposes the collapse of its academic governance.

Institutional Complicity: Post-scandal, the university opted for media silence and backchannel negotiations, enabling the retraction—confirming systemic misconduct by academic leadership. This official shielding of fraud has catastrophically damaged China’s academic ecosystem.

Call to Action:

We urge global universities and academic bodies to monitor WHU’s subsequent actions. International academic pressure is critical to halt the erosion of China’s academic ethics and restore rigorous, impartial scholarship.

best regards


中文版:

我谨代表中国高校广大学子,向全球学术界揭露武汉大学(中国“985工程”重点高校)系统性包庇学术不端的行为。该校不仅纵容严重学术不端的硕士论文通过审核,更在舆论发酵后公然允许涉事学生撤回已发表论文进行篡改,彻底践踏学术伦理底线,暴露出其学术治理机制的全然失效。

事件经过:

2024年5月1日,武汉大学杨景媛的硕士毕业论文《中印生育行为影响家庭暴力的经济学分析》通过武汉大学校内审核并发表于中国知网,即中国国家学位论文数据库(link:中印生育行为影响家庭暴力的经济学分析 - 中国知网)

7月27日,论文《中印生育行为影响家庭暴力的经济学分析》被曝出涉嫌抄袭、事实编造、数据捏造、疑似AI代写、核心模型原理性错误等问题(evidence link:evidenceevidence 1evidence 2evidence 3)。由于武汉大学是一所985大学,在中国享有盛誉,因此该学术丑闻在中国各大社交网站上爆火,累计浏览量超过千万。

8月5日晚,杨在其网盘中上传了一份名为 杨景媛-硕士学位论文调查审核.zip 的文件,该文件在被网友发现后现已删除,(该文件的备份地址:backup)。文件中是对其论文的“修正说明”,并透露出这么一句话:“我愿意在今后的修改过程中积极配合学校、学院及各位老师的要求,认真修正存在问题,不断提升科研工作的严谨性与规范性”。据此,我们合理怀疑校方非但未启动追责程序,反而默许当事人撤回已发表论文进行修改,此举彻底颠覆学术底线开创了中国大学“重大学术不端行为不仅不用受到处罚,甚至可以撤回修改”的先例,此举等同于允许考生在交卷评分后篡改答卷,不仅亵渎学术公正、践踏诚信学子的尊严,更使学术监督机制沦为笑柄。

事件性质:首先,硕士论文需经开题、盲审、答辩等全年闭环审核,而武汉大学竟使漏洞百出的论文全流程通关,暴露其学术治理体系的全面崩溃。其次,丑闻曝光后校方选择舆论缄默与私下操作,纵容当事人撤回论文的渎职行为,充分印证其学术管理层的系统性失职。这种官方庇护学术不端的行径,已对中国学术生态造成毁灭性冲击。

呼吁全球高校与学术组织共同监督武汉大学的后续处理,以国际学术力量遏止中国学术伦理的持续滑坡,助力重建公正严谨的学术环境。



已经在拟邮件了,如果这事是真的,就转成英文发给全球各大高校的邮箱

到时候发邮件的时候不花大笔墨写诬告的情节,会偏离重点

就抓住武汉大学官方疑似允许并包庇学术不端这个点

如果武大当了这个始作俑者,那就是彻底刷新了中国学术底线,损害的是所有中国高校学子的利益

咱为了学术的公义,奉陪到底

戳泡泡
自由评论 (0)
分享
Copyright © 2022 GreatFire.org